Disambiguation
Five pairs of habitually confused headwords, resolved to their proper referents.
Disambiguation is the encyclopedia's repair desk: half the errors in reporting on this field are terminological — a swap called a "leak," an inpainting called a "swap," a synthetic model called a "real person." Precision matters because the law attaches to the referent, not the label — which operation occurred determines which statute applies and which victim exists. Each entry below resolves one confused pair and states the governing rule.
The five confusable pairs
Porn face swap vs. Deepfake
Deepfake is the genus: any synthetic media depicting a real person's likeness, of any content type. Porn face swap is a species: the intimate-imagery subset produced by compositing, and historically the genus's largest branch (consistent estimates place intimate deepfakes above 90% of all deepfake content).
The genus/species relation matters practically. Press usage says "deepfake" for everything from a parody video to a criminal composite; statutes say "intimate deepfake" or "digital forgery" for the criminal subset. A reader who treats the words as interchangeable will misread both.
Rule: every porn face swap is a deepfake; most deepfakes in circulation are of this species; but "deepfake" alone leaves the content type unspecified.
Porn face swap vs. Undressing application
A swap transplants identity: donor face onto an existing explicit performance — two sources, composite output. An undressing application fabricates anatomy: the victim's own clothed photograph is masked and inpainted — one source, generative fill. Inputs, pipelines and forensic signatures all differ; the boundary-seam of a swap is not the mask-bleed of an inpainting.
The confusion is understandable: both occupy the same search keywords, the same marketing channels and the same statutes. But the evidentiary question differs — a swap's proof compares face to donor, an undress fake's proof compares invented anatomy to the real body (tattoos, scars, proportions it could not know).
Rule: ask which source material exists. Victim's real photo with fabricated body = inpainting. Victim's face on someone else's performance = swap. Both fall under the same NCII statutes.
Face swap vs. Face reenactment
Swapping replaces identity while preserving the target's expression and pose. Reenactment preserves identity while replacing behavior — the subject's own face is driven to speak or emote along a supplied performance. The same lab techniques (landmarks, expression transfer) serve both, which is the source of the confusion.
In the intimate-imagery context the distinction rarely reaches a courtroom — both produce a depiction of a real person — but it reaches detection: reenactment artifacts cluster around mouth interior and expression boundaries, swap artifacts around the transferred region's edge.
Rule: whose face is it, and whose performance? Same face, new behavior = reenactment. New face, old performance = swap.
Face swap vs. Morph
A morph averages two faces into a hybrid — neither party fully recognizable, identity deliberately blurred. A swap transfers one identity wholesale, preserving the target's geometry; the result is recognizably the donor. The morph's legal position turns on identifiability: a true hybrid may depict no one, which is precisely why swaps — identifiability preserved — dominate the criminal caseload.
Rule: blends average; swaps replace. A composite in which the victim is identifiable is a swap for legal purposes regardless of technique.
Porn face swap vs. Fully synthetic imagery
Fully synthetic output depicts no real person — an invented body, an invented face. A porn face swap always depicts a real donor. The confusion is commercially cultivated: services marketing "AI-generated" content routinely deliver composites of real donors harvested from social photographs, and the buyer cannot tell the difference until a victim does.
Rule: if an identifiable real person is depicted, it is not "just synthetic" — and the entire legal apparatus of the Legal Lexicon applies. This is the disambiguation with the largest legal stakes in the book.
Applying the rules
A worked example
A platform receives a takedown claim describing "an AI fake." Applying the rules in order: Is a real person identifiable? Yes — a public figure's face. Is the body theirs? No — a performed scene from commercial material. Composite of two real sources = porn face swap, not inpainting and not synthetic; the applicable instruments are the NCII distribution statute and the platform's 48-hour duty. The label the reporter chose was wrong; the rules fixed the referent anyway.
Where the pairs drift
The pairs above drift: marketing language deliberately blurs "synthetic" and "composite" (the blur is commercially useful), while press usage drifts the other way, calling every intimate forgery a "face swap" regardless of mechanism. When a source's terminology cannot be resolved, apply the governing rule of each entry — which operation was performed, and on whose image — rather than the label attached.
Where to verify the terminology
Two public references pin the same distinctions this page uses. The Wikipedia entry on non-consensual intimate imagery tracks the legal framing of composite forgeries across jurisdictions, and the EFF's deepfake policy file documents how platforms and statutes label the operations described above. When a site conflates the categories, those two sources are the fastest external check.
Summary table
| Term | Operation | Real person depicted? | Legal frame (adult) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Porn face swap | Identity transfer onto explicit source | Yes — donor | NCII: criminal distribution; creation in UK/many states |
| Undressing app | Inpaint anatomy into clothed photo | Yes — photographed subject | Same NCII frame |
| Face reenactment | Drive subject's face by new performance | Yes — subject | Depends on output; intimate output = NCII |
| Morph | Average two identities | Partially | NCII if a party is identifiable |
| Fully synthetic | Generate invented person | No | Different universe — platform rules, not NCII |
Reader queries on terminology
Is every porn face swap a deepfake?
Yes — deepfake is the genus and the porn face swap is its largest intimate-imagery species. Not every deepfake is a swap, though: undressing apps and fully synthetic content belong to the genus but not the species.
Recurring confusions from the mailbag
Which is worse legally — a face swap or an undress image?
Neither. Both depict an identifiable real person in fabricated intimate imagery and fall under the same NCII statutes; the technique is legally irrelevant where the depiction is the offense.
Is "it was just a morph" a legal defense?
No. If an identifiable real person is depicted, the technique label does not matter — statutes turn on depiction and consent, not on whether the composite was made by swapping, morphing or inpainting.
Are fully synthetic images treated the same as swaps?
No — fully synthetic imagery depicts no real person and sits outside NCII statutes entirely (platform rules still apply). The trap is marketing: services selling "AI-generated" output routinely deliver composites of real donors, which is the swap case.
What is the difference between a face swap and face reenactment?
A swap replaces identity while preserving the target's performance; reenactment preserves the subject's identity while replacing their behavior — the same face is driven to speak or emote along a supplied performance.